Beef tenderloin is the most tender cut of beef and makes an elegant centerpiece for holidays and dinner parties. It is also one of the most expensive, so it pays to buy the right amount. Whole tenderloins are often sold untrimmed, with fat, silver skin and the chain muscle still attached, which you trim away. This calculator works from the trimmed amount per guest and the trim loss.
How the calculation works
- Trimmed tenderloin = guests × trimmed beef per guest
- Untrimmed weight to buy = trimmed ÷ (1 − trim loss)
- Whole tenderloins = untrimmed weight ÷ weight of one tenderloin, rounded up
- Roasting time per tenderloin = trimmed weight per tenderloin × minutes per pound
For 12 guests at 8 oz each, you need 6.0 lb of trimmed tenderloin. With 25% trim loss, buy 8.0 lb untrimmed, or 2 whole tenderloins of about 6 lb. Each trimmed roast weighs about 3 lb and needs about 36 minutes at 12 minutes per pound in a hot oven, but always check with a thermometer.
How much per person?
| Situation | Trimmed per guest |
|---|---|
| Many sides or a buffet | 5 to 6 oz |
| Main course | 8 oz |
| Hearty eaters | 10 oz |
Trimmed or untrimmed?
An untrimmed whole tenderloin costs less per pound but loses 20 to 30% of its weight. A trimmed, or peeled, tenderloin costs more per pound but is ready to cook. Save the chain muscle and trimmings for stir-fry or kebabs.
Doneness temperatures
- Rare: pull at 115 to 120°F.
- Medium-rare: pull at 125°F, about 130°F after resting.
- Medium: pull at 135°F.
Tips
Fold the thin tail under and tie the roast every 1 to 2 inches so it is an even thickness. Salt it a day ahead, then bring it out of the fridge an hour before cooking. Sear it on all sides, roast at 425°F, and rest it 10 to 15 minutes before slicing into 1-inch medallions. A simple horseradish cream or a red wine sauce complements it well.