Fresh oysters on ice make any gathering feel like a celebration, but they raise practical questions: how many to buy, how long it takes to open them, and what to serve with them. This calculator works out the oysters, the dozens to order, the lemons, the mignonette, the ice, the shucking time and the wine.
How the calculation works
- Oysters = guests × oysters per guest
- Dozens = oysters ÷ 12, rounded up
- Lemons = oysters ÷ oysters per lemon, rounded up
- Mignonette = oysters ÷ oysters per tablespoon
- Ice = oysters ÷ oysters per pound of ice
- Shucking time = oysters × seconds per oyster
- Wine = guests ÷ guests per bottle, rounded up
For 12 guests at 6 oysters each, buy 72 oysters, or 6 dozen. You need about 3 lemons, 12 tablespoons of mignonette sauce and 12 lb of crushed ice for the platters. At about 30 seconds an oyster, shucking takes about 36 minutes, and 3 bottles of dry white wine serve the table.
How many per person?
| Occasion | Oysters per guest |
|---|---|
| A taste among other appetizers | 2 to 3 |
| Appetizer | 6 |
| Main course, oyster lovers | 12 or more |
Buying and storing
- Buy from a trusted seller, and check the harvest tag; keep it for 90 days in the US.
- Choose oysters that are tightly closed and heavy for their size; a tapped open shell that does not close means a dead oyster.
- Store them cupped side down in the fridge, covered with a damp cloth, never in water or a sealed bag. Most keep several days, but eat them as soon as you can.
Shucking and serving
- Use an oyster knife and a thick glove or folded towel. Insert the knife at the hinge, twist to pop it, then slide along the top shell to cut the muscle.
- Keep the liquor inside the shell and pick out any shell fragments.
- Serve on crushed ice with lemon wedges, mignonette (shallot and red wine vinegar), hot sauce and bread with butter.
- A crisp, dry white wine such as Muscadet, Chablis or Sauvignon Blanc, or Champagne, is the classic pairing.
- Raw oysters carry a risk of foodborne illness; people who are pregnant, elderly or have a weakened immune system should eat them cooked.