Pie is the centerpiece of many holiday dessert tables, and guests often want a sliver of two or three kinds. This calculator works out how many pies to bake or buy, how many of each kind, the leftover slices and the cream to whip.
How the calculation works
- Slices eaten = guests × slices per guest
- Pies = slices ÷ slices per pie, rounded up, and at least one of each kind
- Pies of each kind = pies ÷ kinds, rounded up
- Leftover = pies of each kind × kinds × slices per pie − slices eaten
- Cream = total pies × cream per pie
16 guests at 1.25 slices each eat 20 slices. With 8 slices per pie and 3 kinds, bake 3 pies, one of each, with about 4 slices left over. At 1 cup of heavy cream per pie, whip 3 cups.
Slices per guest
With one kind of pie, most guests take one slice. When there are several kinds, people take thinner slices of two or more, so 1.25 to 1.5 slices per guest is a safer plan. After a big holiday meal, appetites are smaller, but leftovers are rarely a problem.
Slices per pie
| Pie | Slices |
|---|---|
| 9 in fruit or pumpkin pie | 8 |
| 9 in rich chocolate or pecan pie | 10 to 12 |
| 10 in deep-dish pie | 10 |
| Slab pie in a sheet pan | 20 to 24 |
Rich pies such as pecan or chocolate cream go further when cut thinner. A slab pie baked in a half-sheet pan is the easiest way to feed a large crowd.
Planning the bake
- Fruit pies can be baked a day ahead and kept at room temperature, loosely covered.
- Pumpkin, custard and cream pies belong in the fridge.
- Pie dough freezes well, so make it a week or two ahead.
- Whip the cream shortly before serving, or stabilize it with a little powdered sugar.
Classic pairings
A popular trio is one fruit pie, such as apple, one custard pie, such as pumpkin, and one nut or chocolate pie, which covers most tastes.