Skip to content
Omnikalc

Beneish M-score calculator: screen a company for earnings manipulation

Enter the eight Beneish indexes (DSRI, GMI, AQI, SGI, DEPI, SGAI, LVGI and TATA) to compute the M-score, the probability of earnings manipulation and a rating from unlikely to likely manipulator.

Updated on
Your inputs

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Results

Beneish M-score

-2.11

Between −2.22 and −1.78: gray zone, look closer
Probit probability of manipulation
1.74 %
Contribution of the accruals to the M-score
0.094

Earnings can be flattered. The Beneish M-score uses eight financial ratios to estimate the chance that a company manipulates its earnings. The Beneish M-score calculator gives the score, the probability of the probit model and a rating from unlikely to likely manipulator.

How the calculation works

  • Compute the eight indexes from two consecutive years of financial statements (year t against year t−1), or enter them from your spreadsheet.
  • DSRI compares receivables to sales, GMI the gross margins, AQI the share of soft assets, SGI the sales growth, DEPI the depreciation rates, SGAI the overhead to sales, LVGI the leverage and TATA the accruals to assets.
  • The calculator applies the eight-variable model of Messod Beneish: M = −4.84 + 0.920 DSRI + 0.528 GMI + 0.404 AQI + 0.892 SGI + 0.115 DEPI − 0.172 SGAI + 4.679 TATA − 0.327 LVGI.
  • A score above −1.78 points to a likely manipulator, and one between −2.22 and −1.78 is a gray zone. The result also gives the probit probability.

Example

A company has a DSRI of 1.10, a GMI of 1.05, an AQI of 1.10, an SGI of 1.15, a DEPI of 1.00, an SGAI of 1.00, a LVGI of 1.05 and TATA of 0.02. The M-score is −2.11: in the gray zone between −2.22 and −1.78. The probability of manipulation given by the probit model is 1.74 %, and the accruals add 0.094 to the score.

Why it matters

The calculator helps investors, analysts, auditors and students to screen a stock for accounting red flags, to complement the Altman Z-score and the Piotroski F-score and to know where to look in the statements. It is a way to ask better questions.

Good to know

The M-score is a screening model fitted on past cases, and it is wrong in some cases in both directions. It uses ratios from reported numbers, which depend on the accounting standard and on one-off events. A high score is not evidence of fraud, and a low one is not a proof of honesty. This is an education tool, and not financial or legal advice.

The Altman Z-score calculator estimates the risk of bankruptcy, the Piotroski F-score calculator rates the financial strength, the accrual ratio calculator measures the quality of earnings, and the retained earnings calculator follows the equity.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Beneish M-score?

Messod Beneish, an accounting professor, published in 1999 a statistical model to find the companies that manipulate their earnings. It uses eight ratios computed from the financial statements of two years. He fitted the model on companies that were sanctioned for manipulation, and it was used by students of Cornell to find Enron as a likely manipulator before its fall in 2001.

What do the eight indexes mean?

DSRI above 1 means that receivables grow faster than sales, a sign of revenue pushed into the period. GMI above 1 means that the margins fall. AQI above 1 shows more costs moved into assets. SGI is the growth: fast-growing companies are under pressure. DEPI above 1 shows slower depreciation. SGAI measures the overhead. LVGI is the debt, and TATA is the accruals, the gap between profit and cash flow.

What threshold should I use?

Beneish proposed −1.78 as the cutoff in the original eight-variable model, which flags the companies above it as likely manipulators. Many analysts use −2.22 as a more cautious threshold, which catches more cases but has more false alarms. The calculator shows both. A score is a flag to look deeper, and not a proof of fraud.

What are the limits of the model?

The model was fitted on US manufacturing companies from 1982 to 1992 and works less well for banks, insurers, young companies and other countries. It gives a probability, so many honest companies are flagged. The inputs depend on the accounting rules and on one-off events such as acquisitions. Use it with the analysis of the notes, of the audit report and of the cash flows.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.