The IRS separates a business, which is run to make a profit, from a hobby, which is done for pleasure. The difference matters because hobby income is taxable but hobby expenses are not deductible. The deduction for miscellaneous expenses has been suspended since 2018 and is now permanent, so a hobbyist pays tax on the full income even if the expenses were as large. A business, in contrast, deducts expenses and pays tax on the net profit, but also owes self-employment tax.
How the calculation works
- Hobby tax = income × your income tax rate. The expenses are not deductible.
- Business net profit = income − expenses
- Business income tax = net profit × your income tax rate
- Self-employment tax = net profit × 92.35 % × 15.3 %
- Tax saved = hobby tax − (business income tax + self-employment tax)
Example
Your activity earns $8,000 and costs $5,000, so the net profit as a business is $3,000. Treated as a hobby, the federal tax is $1,760 because the $5,000 of expenses is not deductible. Treated as a business, the total is $1,084, so business treatment saves $676. As a hobby, the tax equals 59 % of your real profit.
Why it matters
The IRS looks at nine factors, including whether you keep good records, run the activity in a businesslike way, depend on the income, and have the expertise to make a profit. There is a presumption of a business if you show a profit in three of the last five years (two of seven for horse activities). A real business also lets you deduct a loss against other income, which a hobby never does.
Good to know
A hobby’s income goes on Schedule 1 as other income, while a business uses Schedule C. Some states still let hobbyists deduct expenses. The qualified business income deduction can reduce a business’s tax further. Selling a collection or item at a profit is usually a capital gain, not hobby income, and may be treated differently.
In practice
Keep records of income and expenses, a separate bank account and a business plan, and take steps to make the activity profitable. This tool is educational and is not tax advice.