Skip to content
Omnikalc

Should I choose a higher deductible?

Compare the premium you save with a higher deductible against the extra you pay when you make a claim, and see how often you can claim before the low deductible wins.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Value out of range

Results

Expected savings per year with the high deductible

$150

The higher deductible should save money on average, if you can afford it when a claim comes

Break-even: years between claims

2.5

Premium saved per year
$200
Expected extra out of pocket per year
$50

This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.

Choosing a higher deductible lowers your premium, but you pay more out of pocket when you make a claim. Whether it pays off depends on how often you expect to claim. This calculator compares the two options on average, per year.

How the calculation works

With a $500 deductible, the premium is $1,500 a year. With a $1,000 deductible, it is $1,300.

  • Premium saved: 1,500 − 1,300 = $200 a year.
  • Extra cost per claim: 1,000 − 500 = $500.
  • Expected extra cost: with 0.1 claims a year (one claim every 10 years), 0.1 × 500 = $50 a year.
  • Expected savings: 200 − 50 = $150 a year.

Break-even: the $500 extra per claim takes 500 ÷ 200 = 2.5 years of premium savings to earn back. If you claim more often than once every 2.5 years, the low deductible costs less on average; less often, the high deductible wins.

Estimating how often you claim

Look at your own history over the past 5 to 10 years. Many households file a home or auto claim only once every several years. Small claims are often not worth filing anyway, since a claim can raise future premiums, which also favors a higher deductible.

When a low deductible still makes sense

  • No savings buffer: a high deductible only works if you can pay it the day something goes wrong. Keep at least the deductible amount in your emergency fund; the emergency fund calculator can help.
  • Frequent claims, for example a young driver or a home in a hail-prone area.
  • Small premium difference: if the higher deductible saves very little, the extra risk may not be worth it.

Health insurance is different

For health plans, the comparison also includes copays, coinsurance and the out-of-pocket maximum, and expected medical costs vary a lot by person and by year. High-deductible plans may also allow a health savings account. Use this calculator only as a rough first comparison there, and check plan documents for the full picture.

Tips

Ask your insurer for quotes at several deductible levels: the premium savings often shrink at the highest levels. Review the choice when your savings grow or your situation changes.

Frequently asked questions

Is a higher deductible worth it?

Usually, if you claim rarely and can afford the deductible; in the example it saves $150 a year on average.

How do I find the break-even point for a deductible?

Divide the deductible difference by the premium saved per year: $500 ÷ $200 = 2.5 years between claims.

Should I keep savings for my deductible?

Yes. Keep at least the deductible amount in an emergency fund.

Does this work for health insurance?

Only roughly, since health plans also have copays, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximums.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.