This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.
Choosing a higher deductible lowers your premium, but you pay more out of pocket when you make a claim. Whether it pays off depends on how often you expect to claim. This calculator compares the two options on average, per year.
How the calculation works
With a $500 deductible, the premium is $1,500 a year. With a $1,000 deductible, it is $1,300.
- Premium saved: 1,500 − 1,300 = $200 a year.
- Extra cost per claim: 1,000 − 500 = $500.
- Expected extra cost: with 0.1 claims a year (one claim every 10 years), 0.1 × 500 = $50 a year.
- Expected savings: 200 − 50 = $150 a year.
Break-even: the $500 extra per claim takes 500 ÷ 200 = 2.5 years of premium savings to earn back. If you claim more often than once every 2.5 years, the low deductible costs less on average; less often, the high deductible wins.
Estimating how often you claim
Look at your own history over the past 5 to 10 years. Many households file a home or auto claim only once every several years. Small claims are often not worth filing anyway, since a claim can raise future premiums, which also favors a higher deductible.
When a low deductible still makes sense
- No savings buffer: a high deductible only works if you can pay it the day something goes wrong. Keep at least the deductible amount in your emergency fund; the emergency fund calculator can help.
- Frequent claims, for example a young driver or a home in a hail-prone area.
- Small premium difference: if the higher deductible saves very little, the extra risk may not be worth it.
Health insurance is different
For health plans, the comparison also includes copays, coinsurance and the out-of-pocket maximum, and expected medical costs vary a lot by person and by year. High-deductible plans may also allow a health savings account. Use this calculator only as a rough first comparison there, and check plan documents for the full picture.
Tips
Ask your insurer for quotes at several deductible levels: the premium savings often shrink at the highest levels. Review the choice when your savings grow or your situation changes.