Skip to content
Omnikalc

Job offer comparison: which offer is really worth more?

Enter the salary, bonus, retirement match, premiums, paid days off and commute of two job offers to compare their total yearly value.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

% of salary

Value out of range

% of salary

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

days

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

% of salary

Value out of range

% of salary

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

days

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Results

Offer A minus offer B (total yearly value)

$3,255

Offer A is worth more in total
Total yearly value of offer A
$92,635
Total yearly value of offer B
$89,380
Offer A: value of days off above 10
$1,635
Offer B: value of days off above 10
$3,600
Gap as a share of the larger offer
3.5%

A bigger salary doesn’t always mean a better offer. A smaller base can come with a richer retirement match, cheaper health insurance, more paid time off and a shorter, cheaper commute. This calculator turns each offer into one comparable yearly figure so you can see which really pays more, and by how much.

How the calculation works

  • Total value = salary × (1 + bonus % + retirement match %) + value of days off + other benefits − health premium − commuting cost
  • Value of days off = (days off − 10) × salary ÷ 260 (one day of pay each)

Everything is expressed in yearly dollars, before taxes. A bonus is counted at its expected value, not at the maximum.

Example

Offer A pays $85,000 with an 8 % bonus, a 4 % match, 15 days off, a $2,400 premium and $1,800 of commuting. Offer B pays $78,000 with 5 %, a 6 % match, 22 days off, a $1,200 premium, $600 of commuting and a $1,000 stipend. Total values: A $92,635 against B $89,380. Offer A is better by $3,255 a year, or 3.5 %: despite fewer days off, the higher salary wins. With a higher bonus on B, the order could change.

Why it matters

The headline salary is the most visible number and the easiest to compare, so it takes too much weight. Putting a value on everything else often shrinks the gap, and sometimes reverses it. It also gives you concrete numbers to negotiate: knowing that a week of extra vacation or a 2 % higher match is worth about as much as $1,500 gives you a way to ask for what matters to you.

Good to know

This comparison is before taxes; benefits such as insurance and retirement contributions are taxed differently from salary, so consider the after-tax picture for large gaps. Bonuses are not guaranteed, and a retirement match may vest over several years. Cost of living differs between cities: compare after housing costs if the jobs are in different places. This tool is for education.

The federal income tax calculator estimates take-home pay, the cost of living calculator compares cities, and the 401(k) employer match calculator values the match in detail.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare two job offers?

Put a yearly dollar value on each part of the package: salary, bonus, retirement match, benefits and paid time off, minus the costs you bear such as insurance premiums and commuting. Then compare the totals and weigh the non-financial factors.

How is paid time off valued?

Each day off above a baseline of 10 days is valued at one day of pay (salary ÷ 260 working days). It is a way to compare the offers, because more vacation at the same salary means a higher hourly rate.

What should I leave out of the comparison?

Things you can't price easily: the commute time itself, the team, the growth prospects, the stability of the company and the work you will do. They often matter more than a gap of a few percent.

How do I treat equity or a signing bonus?

Put them in 'other benefits' as a yearly value. For a signing bonus, divide it by the years you expect to stay. Stock options and unvested shares are uncertain, so count them at a discount.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.