This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.
Every holiday season brings the same question: buy a fresh tree again, or invest in an artificial one? This calculator compares the cost of both over the years you would keep an artificial tree and shows how long it takes to pay for itself.
The math
A real tree at $90 plus $10 a year for a stand, delivery or disposal costs $100 a year. Over 10 years that is $1,000. An artificial tree at $250, kept for 10 years, works out to $25 a year. It pays for itself after 250 ÷ 100 = 2.5 years and saves $750 over the period.
The artificial tree only wins if you keep it long enough. If it gets damaged or you replace it after a few seasons for a new style, the savings shrink.
More than money
Real trees:
- Have the scent and look many people love, and choosing one can be a family tradition.
- Are grown on farms as a crop, often replanted after harvest, and can be recycled into mulch through local programs.
- Need watering and can shed needles; a dry tree is a fire risk.
Artificial trees:
- Are reusable, often pre-lit, and need no watering or needle cleanup.
- Are usually made of plastic and metal, often shipped from overseas, and hard to recycle at the end of their life.
- Need storage space for the rest of the year.
Studies comparing their environmental impact generally find that an artificial tree has to be reused for many years to match a real tree that is recycled, so keeping an artificial tree a long time matters both for cost and for the environment.
Tips
- Real trees: buy from a local farm, make a fresh cut at the base and keep the stand full of water; check whether your town collects trees for chipping.
- Artificial trees: buy one sturdy enough to last a decade, store it in a bag or box in a dry place, and check light strings before plugging in.
- Either way: keep the tree away from heaters and fireplaces and turn off lights when you go to bed.