Skip to content
Omnikalc

Is buying refurbished cheaper than new?

Compare a new and a refurbished phone, laptop or appliance by the cost per year of use, the upfront saving and the minimum life the refurbished one needs to be the better deal.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

years

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

years

Value out of range

Results

Refurbished cost per year

$216.67

Refurbished is cheaper per year of use

New cost per year

$225.00

Minimum life for refurbished to win

2.9 years

Saving at purchase
$250
Refurbished discount
27.8%

This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.

Refurbished phones, laptops and appliances are cheaper than new, but they may not last as long. The fair way to compare them is the cost per year of use. This calculator works out the cost per year of each option, the upfront saving and the minimum time the refurbished one must last to be the better deal.

How the calculation works

  • Cost per year = price ÷ years you will use it
  • Saving at purchase = new price − refurbished price
  • Minimum life for refurbished to win = refurbished price ÷ new cost per year

A new phone at $900 kept for 4 years costs $225 a year. A refurbished one at $650, a 27.8% discount, kept for 3 years costs $216.67 a year. Refurbished wins as long as it lasts at least 2.9 years, because 650 ÷ 225 = 2.9.

What refurbished means

A refurbished device has usually been returned, repaired or used, then tested, cleaned and resold. The quality varies a lot between sellers:

  • Manufacturer refurbished devices are often close to new, with a fresh battery and a warranty similar to new.
  • Seller refurbished devices are checked by a third party; quality depends on the seller and the grade.
  • Cosmetic grades describe scratches and marks, not how well the device works.

What to check before buying

  • Warranty length and who provides it.
  • Battery health for phones and laptops, since a worn battery shortens the useful life.
  • Return policy, in case something is wrong.
  • Software updates: an older model may stop receiving security updates sooner, which can end its life early regardless of the hardware.

Adding resale value

If you usually sell your old device, subtract the expected resale price from the purchase price before entering it. A new phone often resells for more than a refurbished one of an older model, which can narrow the gap.

Beyond the money

Buying refurbished keeps devices in use longer and avoids the materials and energy needed to make a new one. When the cost per year is close, that can tip the balance. When a device is critical for your work, a longer warranty and a known battery state matter as much as the price.

Frequently asked questions

Is refurbished cheaper than new per year?

In the example, $216.67 a year refurbished vs $225 new.

How long must a refurbished phone last?

In the example, at least 2.9 years to beat a new one.

What should I check before buying refurbished?

The warranty, battery health, return policy and software update support.

Is refurbished as good as new?

Manufacturer refurbished is often close to new; quality varies between sellers.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.