Both a Roth and a traditional retirement account give you a tax break, but at different times. A traditional account lowers your tax today and taxes the money when you take it out. A Roth gets no deduction today but is tax-free on the way out. Which one leaves you with more depends mostly on one question: will your tax rate be higher or lower in retirement? This calculator compares the two for the same amount of pre-tax pay.
How the calculation works
For the same amount of pre-tax salary:
- Growth multiple = (1 + return)^years
- Traditional = amount × growth multiple × (1 − tax rate in retirement)
- Roth = amount × (1 − tax rate today) × growth multiple
The two accounts are equal when the tax rate today and in retirement are the same: the order of multiplication doesn’t change the product.
Example
You can set aside $7,000 of pre-tax pay. Your tax rate today is 24 % and you expect 18 % in retirement, 25 years from now, with a 7 % return. The growth multiple is 5.43. Traditional: 7,000 × 5.43 × 0.82 = $31,153. Roth: 7,000 × 0.76 × 5.43 = $28,874. The traditional account leaves $2,280 more. If your rate in retirement were 28 %, the Roth would win.
Why it matters
This is one of the most common retirement choices, and it comes down to a forecast of your own tax rate. Early in a career, with a low bracket, a Roth is often attractive; at peak earning, a traditional account usually is. Splitting between them gives tax diversification and protects against a surprise in future tax law.
Good to know
This comparison assumes you invest the same pre-tax amount in both cases. If you can’t afford to pay the tax on a Roth contribution out of other money, the comparison changes: a Roth contribution is worth more as a share of your wealth, because it shelters more money. Required distributions, the tax on Social Security benefits and state taxes in retirement can raise your retirement rate. This tool is for education and is not tax advice.
Related tools
The retirement savings calculator projects a nest egg, the 401(k) employer match calculator values the match, and the federal income tax calculator finds your bracket.