A sole proprietor pays self-employment tax on every dollar of profit, up to the Social Security wage base. An S corporation owner pays payroll tax only on a reasonable salary, and takes the rest of the profit as distributions. This calculator estimates the tax saved and what is left after the extra yearly costs of running an S corp.
How the calculation works
- Sole proprietor tax = 12.4 % × (net profit × 92.35 %, up to the wage base) + 2.9 % × (net profit × 92.35 %)
- S corp payroll tax = 12.4 % × (salary, up to the wage base) + 2.9 % × salary
- Saving = sole proprietor tax − S corp payroll tax
- Net saving = saving − extra yearly costs
- Distributions = profit − salary − employer half of payroll tax
Example
A business earns $100,000. As a sole proprietor, $92,350 is subject to tax and the self-employment tax is $14,130. As an S corp with a $50,000 salary, payroll tax is $7,650, so the gross saving is $6,480. After $2,500 of extra costs the net saving is $3,980, and $46,175 of profit is left as distributions.
Why it matters
For a profitable freelancer, payroll tax is often the biggest tax bill after income tax. Comparing a sole proprietorship with an S corp at several salaries shows the range of savings and when the extra cost starts to outweigh them.
Good to know
This calculator ignores the Medicare surtax, state taxes, the qualified business income deduction and the effect of a lower salary on future Social Security benefits and on retirement plan limits. The wage base is set each year. It is an estimate and not tax advice; ask a CPA. Also remember that a salary that is too low can be recharacterized by the IRS, with back taxes and penalties, and that the S corp must run payroll, file its own return and keep clean books to qualify.
Related tools
The self-employment tax calculator shows the sole proprietor side in detail, the income tax calculator estimates the rest of your bill, and the gross to net salary calculator turns a salary into take-home pay.