Two retirees can earn exactly the same average return and end with very different savings. The difference is the sequence of returns: when you withdraw money every year, losses at the start hurt much more than losses at the end, because you sell shares at low prices and have less left to recover. This calculator compares the final balance of the same portfolio when the weak years come first and when they come last.
How the calculation works
For a block of n years with a yearly return r and a withdrawal W at the end of each year:
- Balance after the block = start × (1 + r)ⁿ − W × ((1 + r)ⁿ − 1) ÷ r
- The balance never goes below zero: a portfolio that is empty stays empty.
- Average return = ((1 + r₁)ⁿ¹ × (1 + r₂)ⁿ²)^(1 ÷ total years) − 1
The two scenarios use the same two blocks of years, only in a different order.
Example
You start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $35,000 a year. The market gives 5 weak years at −10 % and 25 strong years at +8 %, which is an average of 4.77 % a year in both cases. If the weak years come first, the portfolio falls to $447,162 after five years and ends at $503,667. If they come last, it ends at $2,389,736. The order alone makes a difference of $1,886,070, although you withdrew the same $1,050,000 in both cases.
Why it matters
In the saving years, the order of returns does not matter for the final amount, because nothing is withdrawn. In retirement it matters a great deal. This risk is the reason behind the guidance on safe withdrawal rates, cash buffers, flexible spending and holding some bonds in the first years of retirement.
Good to know
The model uses a constant return in each block and withdrawals at year end, so it simplifies real markets, where returns change every year and inflation raises spending. A real plan would test many sequences, including a run of poor years right after the start. Fees and taxes also reduce the returns, so use figures after costs. The result is an illustration, not a forecast.
In practice
To reduce the risk, you can lower the first withdrawals after a bad year, keep one to three years of spending in cash or short bonds, delay the start of the withdrawals, or have an income that does not depend on the market. Try a larger withdrawal in the calculator to see when the weak-years-first case runs out of money. This tool is for education and is not financial advice.