A variable annuity is an insurance contract in which your money is invested in funds, and it grows tax-deferred until you withdraw it. It is sold with several layers of fees: a mortality and expense charge (an insurance and administration fee), the fees of the funds inside the contract and the cost of optional riders that add guarantees, such as a minimum income or death benefit. Together they often reach 2 % to 3 % a year, much more than the cost of an index fund. This calculator shows the total fees, the value of the annuity and of an index fund, the value lost to extra fees and the result after tax.
How the calculation works
- Annuity growth rate = return − insurance fee − fund fees − rider fees
- Annuity value = amount × (1 + growth rate)^years
- Index fund value = amount × (1 + return − fund fee)^years
- Value lost = index fund value − annuity value
- After tax: annuity gains are taxed at your ordinary rate, and index fund gains at the capital gains rate
Example
You invest $100,000 for 20 years at a 7 % return. The annuity charges 1.25 %, 0.75 % and 1 % for riders, 3.00 % a year in all, and it grows to $219,112. An index fund that costs 0.1 % grows to $379,799. The extra fees cost $160,687 before tax. After tax, the annuity is worth $190,525 and the index fund $337,829, so the index fund comes out $147,304 ahead.
Why it matters
A small difference in yearly fees becomes a large difference over decades, because the lost money would also have grown. Tax deferral, the main selling point of an annuity, is worth less than it seems, since gains are taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn, while long-term gains in a taxable account are taxed at lower rates. The extra fees buy insurance guarantees, so the question is whether you value them enough to pay for them.
Good to know
A variable annuity may carry a surrender charge if you withdraw in the first years, often 6 % to 8 % at first. Withdrawals before 59½ are subject to a 10 % penalty on gains. A variable annuity makes the most sense when you have already used other tax-advantaged accounts such as a 401(k) and an IRA, expect a high tax rate now and a lower one later and want the guarantees. Annuities held in a retirement account get no extra tax benefit, because the account is already tax-deferred. Ask for the full fee schedule in writing.
In practice
Add up every fee, compare the guarantees with what you could buy separately and consider low-cost alternatives before you sign. This tool is educational and is not financial advice.