Skip to content
Omnikalc

Bertrand's box paradox calculator: why is the chance 2/3 and not 1/2?

Enter the number of gold-gold, mixed and silver-silver boxes to get the chance that the second coin is gold after you draw a gold coin first.

Updated on
Your inputs

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Results

Chance that the second coin is gold, given that the first is gold

66.67 %

Chance that the first coin drawn is gold
50.00 %
Gap with the naive guess of 50 %
16.67 pts
Draws that start with a gold coin
150.0
Of those, draws where the second coin is gold too
100.0
Of those, draws where the second coin is silver
50.0

Seeing a gold coin makes a second gold coin more likely than you think. The Bertrand’s box paradox calculator takes the number of gold-gold, mixed and silver-silver boxes and gives the chance that the second coin is gold, the chance of starting with gold, the gap with the naive 50 % and the expected number of draws of each kind over many repetitions.

How the calculation works

  • Enter how many boxes hold two gold coins, one gold and one silver coin, and two silver coins. The classic puzzle has one box of each kind.
  • Pick a box at random and a coin at random from it. Suppose the coin you see is gold. The calculator gives the chance that the other coin in the same box is gold too.
  • The answer is 2a ÷ (2a + b), where a is the number of gold-gold boxes and b the number of mixed boxes. With one box of each kind it is 2/3, not the 1/2 that most people expect.
  • Enter a number of repeated draws to see how many of them start with gold, and how many of those end with a second gold coin.

Example

Three boxes hold two gold, one gold and one silver, and two silver coins, and you repeat the draw 300 times. Half of the draws, 150, start with a gold coin, because 3 of the 6 coins are gold. Those 3 gold coins are the two from the gold-gold box and one from the mixed box, so the second coin is gold in 2 out of 3 cases, that is 66.67 %, or 100 draws out of 150.

Why it matters

The puzzle is a classic way to teach conditional probability. It shows why counting coins, not boxes, is the right way to reason, and the same idea applies to medical tests, quality control and any case where you learn something about an item before judging the rest.

Good to know

The result assumes that the box is chosen at random and then a coin is chosen at random inside it, with every coin equally likely. If the coin were chosen in a different way, for example by always showing the gold one first, the probabilities would change. The repeated draws give expected numbers, not exact outcomes.

The Monty Hall calculator works through another famous counterintuitive puzzle, and the Bayes’ theorem calculator updates a probability after new evidence.

Frequently asked questions

What is Bertrand's box paradox?

It is a probability puzzle published by Joseph Bertrand in 1889. Three boxes hold two gold coins, one gold and one silver coin, and two silver coins. You pick a box at random, take out a coin without looking, and it is gold. What is the chance that the other coin is gold too? Many people say 1/2, but the answer is 2/3.

Why is the answer 2/3 and not 1/2?

Because you are more likely to have drawn the gold coin from the box that holds two of them. Label the three gold coins: two belong to the gold-gold box and only one to the mixed box. Each gold coin is equally likely to be the one you see, so in two cases out of three the other coin is gold.

How does Bayes' theorem explain it?

The chance of drawing gold is 1 for the gold-gold box, 1/2 for the mixed box and 0 for the silver-silver box. After you see gold, the silver-silver box is ruled out, and the gold-gold box is twice as likely as the mixed box. Weighting the boxes by these likelihoods gives 2/3 for the gold-gold box.

Is it related to the Monty Hall problem?

Yes. Both puzzles show that new information changes the odds in a way that intuition misses, and both are solved by counting the equally likely cases instead of the number of boxes or doors left. The calculator also lets you try other mixes of boxes.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.