Skip to content
Omnikalc

Is a hotel or a vacation rental cheaper for my trip?

Compare hotel rooms with a vacation rental for your group, including cleaning and service fees, lodging taxes and the money saved by cooking.

Updated on
Your inputs

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Results

Hotel total

$2,016

Rental total after cooking savings

$1,449

The rental comes out cheaper
Rental total before cooking savings
$1,749
Hotel rooms needed
2
Difference (hotel minus rental)
$567
Rental cost per person per night
$72.46

For a family or a group of friends, a vacation rental with several bedrooms and a kitchen can cost less than hotel rooms, or more once fees are added. This calculator compares both options for your trip, including cleaning fees, service fees, lodging taxes and the savings from cooking your own meals.

Hotel cost

A standard hotel room sleeps 2 to 4 people. The calculator works out the rooms you need from your group size and multiplies by the nightly rate and the nights, then adds lodging taxes. Four people at 2 per room need 2 rooms: 5 nights × 2 rooms × $180 = $1,800, or $2,016 with 12% tax. Watch for resort fees and parking charges, which some hotels add per night.

Vacation rental cost

A rental is priced per night for the whole place, plus a one-time cleaning fee and a booking platform’s service fee, which is often 10 to 15%. Lodging taxes usually apply too. In the example, 5 nights at $250 plus a $120 cleaning fee is $1,370, or about $1,749 after a 14% service fee and 12% tax. Cleaning fees weigh heavily on short stays, so rentals tend to pay off over longer trips.

The kitchen effect

A rental kitchen lets you cook breakfast and some dinners. If that saves $15 per person per day, a family of 4 saves $300 over 5 nights, bringing the rental to about $1,449, roughly $567 less than the hotel.

Beyond price

  • Space: rentals offer separate bedrooms, a living room and often laundry.
  • Services: hotels include daily housekeeping, a front desk, and often breakfast or a pool.
  • Flexibility: hotel cancellation is often more forgiving; rentals may require a deposit and strict cancellation terms.
  • Location: compare the travel time and cost to what you plan to do.

Tips

  • Compare the total price with all fees, not the nightly rate shown first.
  • For long stays, many rentals offer weekly or monthly discounts.
  • Read reviews about cleanliness, noise and accuracy of photos.
  • Check whether the hotel rate includes breakfast before comparing food savings.

Frequently asked questions

Is a vacation rental cheaper than a hotel?

Often for groups and longer stays, once cleaning and service fees are counted.

What fees does a vacation rental add?

A cleaning fee, a service fee of about 10 to 15%, and lodging taxes.

How much does a kitchen save?

About $300 for 4 people over 5 nights at $15 per person per day.

How many hotel rooms for 4 people?

Two standard rooms at 2 per room, or one family room.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.