Skip to content
Omnikalc

Which deal is better: buy one get one, second half off or percent off?

Compare buy X get Y free, a discount on the second item and a straight percentage off, with the real discount and the price per unit of each.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

Results

Buy X get Y free: real discount

33.3%

Best deal here

Second item discount: real discount

25.0%

Price per item with buy X get Y
$2.67
Price per item with the second-item discount
$3.00
Straight percent off
30.0%
Price per item with percent off
$2.80

This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.

Stores love multi-buy offers: buy one get one free, buy 2 get 1 free, second item half off. They are not always the bargains they seem, and they are hard to compare with a simple percentage discount. This calculator turns each offer into a real discount and a price per item.

Buy X get Y free

You pay for X items and receive X + Y. The real discount is Y ÷ (X + Y):

  • Buy 1 get 1 free: 50% off each item.
  • Buy 2 get 1 free: 33.3% off.
  • Buy 3 get 1 free: 25% off.

At $4 an item, buy 2 get 1 free means paying $8 for 3 items, $2.67 each.

Second item at a discount

“Second item half off” means 50% off one of two items, which is 25% off overall. “Buy one, get one 40% off” is only 20% off. At $4 an item, second half off is $3.00 each.

Straight percent off

A simple percentage off applies to each item, even if you buy just one. 30% off a $4 item is $2.80.

In the example, buy 2 get 1 free wins at 33.3%, ahead of 30% off and second half off at 25%.

The catch: do you need them all?

Multi-buy deals only save money if you use every item. If you need one, a 30% discount on a single item beats buy 2 get 1 free, since the free item costs you $8 for 3 instead of $4 for 1. Watch out for:

  • Perishables that spoil before you use them.
  • Price raises before the promotion: compare the regular price with past prices or other stores.
  • Mix-and-match rules: the cheapest item is usually the free one.
  • Limits and coupons: some stores let you stack a coupon on top of a multi-buy deal, which can make it the best option.

Price per unit

The best check is the price per unit, per ounce or per item, after the deal. Comparing it with the regular price at another store, or with a bigger pack, tells you whether the promotion is really a bargain.

Frequently asked questions

Is buy 2 get 1 free better than 30% off?

Yes, it is 33.3% off, if you use all three items.

What discount is buy one get one free?

50% off each item.

What discount is second item half off?

25% off overall.

When is a multi-buy deal not worth it?

When you would not use every item, or the price rose before the deal.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.