Skip to content
Omnikalc

Should I rent or buy this tool?

Compare renting a tool each time you need it with buying it, keeping it for a few years and reselling it, and find how many uses a year make buying worth it.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

years

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Results

Total cost of renting

$900

Net cost of buying

$380

Buying is cheaper
Uses per year where buying breaks even
1.3
Difference over the period
$520

This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.

A pressure washer, a tile saw, a floor sander, a log splitter: many tools are needed only a few days a year. Renting avoids a big purchase and storage, but rental fees add up if you use the tool often. This calculator compares the two over the years you would own the tool, resale included.

The cost of renting

Multiply the daily rate by the rental days per use, the uses per year and the number of years. At $60 a day, one day at a time, 3 times a year for 5 years, renting costs $900. Rental often also means picking up and returning the tool and paying a deposit.

The cost of buying

Buying costs the purchase price minus what you get back when you sell it, plus upkeep. A $400 tool resold for 30% after 5 years loses $280; add $20 a year for blades, oil and servicing, and the net cost is $380. Buying saves $520 over the period here.

Break-even

Buying wins as soon as you use the tool often enough. Divide the net cost of buying by the rental cost per use over the period: 380 ÷ (60 × 5) = about 1.3 uses a year. If you would use it less than that, rent; if more, buy.

Beyond the price

  • Quality: rental tools are often professional-grade machines; a cheap consumer version may do worse work.
  • Storage: large tools take garage space, which has a cost too.
  • Maintenance: engines need fuel stabilizer, oil changes and winter storage.
  • Convenience: owning means no trip to the rental store and no rush to return it.
  • Sharing: splitting the purchase with a neighbor, or borrowing from a tool library, can beat both options.
  • Resale: well-known brands and well-kept tools resell better.

Tips

  • Rent first to try a tool before buying one.
  • Rent for the big jobs, such as a floor sander or a stump grinder; buy the tools you use every season.
  • Plan rentals to use the tool for several jobs on the same day.
  • Buy used for tools with simple mechanics.

Frequently asked questions

Should I rent or buy a tool?

Buy when you would use it more than the break-even: about 1.3 uses a year in the example.

How much does renting a tool cost over 5 years?

$900 at $60 a day, 3 times a year.

What is the real cost of buying a tool?

The price minus resale value plus upkeep: $380 for a $400 tool resold at 30%.

Which tools are best rented?

Big, specialized tools used rarely, such as floor sanders and stump grinders.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.