Skip to content
Omnikalc

COBRA vs marketplace calculator: which health coverage costs less after you leave a job?

Enter your old and employer premiums, the COBRA fee and the marketplace premium to compare the total cost and the saving from switching.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

months

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Results

COBRA premium per month

$1,020

Net saving from switching, after restarting the deductible

$6,060

Marketplace is cheaper The marketplace plan costs less over the period, even after the deductible restarts.
Increase over what you paid as an employee
$770
COBRA premium as a multiple of your old premium
4.1 times
Total COBRA premiums over the period
$18,360
Total marketplace premiums over the period
$10,800
Premium difference over the period
$7,560

COBRA lets you keep your employer’s group health insurance for up to 18 months after you leave a job, but you pay the whole premium. That means your share plus the part your employer used to pay, and an administrative fee of up to 2 %. The result is often a sharp jump in cost. A plan on the ACA marketplace may cost less, especially if you qualify for a premium tax credit. This calculator shows the COBRA premium, the total cost of each option and the saving from switching.

How the calculation works

  • COBRA premium = (your share + employer share) × (1 + administrative fee)
  • Increase = COBRA premium − what you paid as an employee
  • Total COBRA = monthly premium × months of coverage
  • Total marketplace = monthly premium of the new plan × months
  • Net saving = COBRA total − marketplace total − the deductible and out-of-pocket costs that restart on a new plan

Example

You paid $250 a month and your employer paid $750. With a 2 % fee, COBRA costs $1,020 a month, an increase of $770, or 4.1 times what you paid before. Over 18 months, that is $18,360. A marketplace plan at $600 costs $10,800, so you save $7,560 in premiums. After $1,500 of deductible that restarts, the net saving is $6,060.

Why it matters

Losing a job already strains your budget, and COBRA can cost more than rent. Leaving a job is a special enrollment event, which gives you 60 days to choose a marketplace plan, and the credit can make a plan far cheaper. COBRA remains useful when you are in the middle of treatment, are close to your deductible or want to keep your doctors.

Good to know

You have 60 days after the notice to elect COBRA, and the coverage can be back-dated, so you can wait and see if you need it. If you drop COBRA voluntarily, that does not open a new enrollment window, so decide early. A window opens when COBRA runs out. COBRA only applies to employers with at least 20 employees, and state “mini-COBRA” laws can cover smaller ones. The coverage ends sooner if you stop paying or become eligible for another plan. Compare networks, drugs and out-of-pocket maximums, not only premiums.

In practice

Check the marketplace premium for your income, ask your doctors which plans they take and note your COBRA election deadline. This tool is educational and is not insurance advice.

Frequently asked questions

How much does COBRA cost?

You pay the full cost of the plan, both your share and your employer's, plus up to 2 %, so it is often three to five times what you paid before.

How long can I keep COBRA?

Usually up to 18 months after leaving a job, and longer in some cases, such as 29 or 36 months.

Is the marketplace cheaper than COBRA?

Often, especially with a premium tax credit, but compare doctors, drug coverage and the deductible you would restart.

When can I switch from COBRA to the marketplace?

During open enrollment or when a qualifying event occurs. Losing your job coverage gives you a 60-day window to choose a marketplace plan.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.