There are two federal tax breaks for child care. A dependent care FSA lets you set aside pre-tax pay from your employer, up to $5,000 a household, for care expenses, which saves income tax and payroll tax. The Child and Dependent Care Credit gives you a share (typically 20 %) of up to $3,000 of expenses for one child or $6,000 for two or more. You can use both, but the money in the FSA reduces the expenses you can use for the credit. This calculator compares the FSA, the credit and the combination.
How the calculation works
- FSA saving = amount set aside (up to the limit) × (income tax rate + payroll tax rate)
- Expense cap for the credit = $3,000 for one qualifying person, $6,000 for two or more
- Expenses left for the credit = cap (or actual care, if lower) − FSA money
- Credit = remaining expenses × credit rate
- Extra saving from the FSA = FSA saving + credit on the remainder − credit alone
Example
You spend $8,000 a year on care for 2 children, at a 24 % marginal rate. The FSA takes $5,000 and saves $1,582 (24 % income tax plus 7.65 % payroll tax). The cap for the credit is $6,000, so $1,000 is left, and the credit on it is $200. The total is $1,782. The credit alone would save $1,200, so the FSA adds $582.
Why it matters
For most households with a marginal rate above the credit rate, the FSA saves more because it avoids payroll tax and works on a larger amount of expenses. The credit is better for families with low incomes, where the credit rate is higher, or whose employer offers no FSA.
Good to know
The expenses must be needed so that you (and your spouse) can work or look for work, for a child under 13 or a disabled dependent. Payments to a spouse or to a child under 19 do not qualify. You must report the care provider’s name, address and taxpayer number. The FSA is “use it or lose it” within the plan rules, and the payroll tax savings apply only below the Social Security wage base. The credit rate, the cap and the FSA limit have been changed by law and may change again.
In practice
Sign up during open enrollment, keep receipts and a provider’s tax ID and run the comparison again if your income or child care changes. This tool is educational and is not tax advice.