Skip to content
Omnikalc

Is fresh-squeezed orange juice cheaper than store-bought?

Enter the juice you drink a week, the fruit it takes per cup, the fruit price and the store-bought juice price: get the fruit per week, the cost per cup of each, and the yearly cost and difference.

Updated on
Your inputs
cups

Value out of range

lb

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Results

Fresh juice per cup

$1.44

Extra cost of fresh juice per year

$319.41

Juicing oranges are cheapest in winter and when bought by the case; drink fresh juice within a day, and remember whole fruit gives more fiber than juice
Oranges per week
8.4 lb
Store-bought per cup
$0.56
Fresh juice per year
$524.16
Store-bought per year
$204.75

This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional. Freshly squeezed orange juice tastes wonderful, but it takes a surprising amount of fruit. This calculator compares the cost of squeezing your own with buying juice by the carton, per cup and per year, so you can see what the fresh taste costs you.

How the calculation works

  • Oranges per week = juice per week × oranges per cup of juice
  • Fresh juice per cup = oranges per cup × price per lb
  • Store-bought per cup = carton price ÷ 8 cups per half gallon
  • Yearly cost = cost per cup × cups per week × 52
  • Extra cost of fresh juice = fresh yearly cost − store-bought yearly cost

Drinking 7 cups of fresh juice a week takes about 8.4 lb of oranges at 1.2 lb per cup. At $1.20 a lb, fresh juice costs about $1.44 a cup, or $524.16 a year. Store-bought juice at $4.50 a half gallon costs about $0.56 a cup, or $204.75 a year, so fresh juice costs about $319.41 more each year.

How much fruit for a cup of juice

Fruit Fruit per cup of juice
Juicing oranges (Valencia) about 3 oranges, 1 to 1.5 lb
Navel oranges 3 to 4 oranges
Grapefruit 1 to 1.5 grapefruit
Lemons 5 to 6 lemons

Juicy, thin-skinned oranges such as Valencias give more juice than thick-skinned navels. Rolling the fruit on the counter and using it at room temperature also helps.

Lowering the cost

  • Buy by the bag or the case, when oranges are in season, usually winter and early spring.
  • Mix fresh juice with water or sparkling water, or mix orange with cheaper carrot or apple.
  • Use a good juicer: a lever press or electric citrus juicer extracts more than squeezing by hand.
  • Use the peel of organic fruit as zest for baking before juicing.

Fresh, not-from-concentrate or concentrate?

Juice “not from concentrate” is pasteurized and often stored for months; juice from concentrate is cheaper still. Fresh-squeezed juice has the most aroma but loses vitamin C and flavor within a day, so squeeze it just before drinking and keep any leftover juice cold and covered.

A note on health

Even fresh juice is high in sugar and low in fiber compared with whole fruit. Health guidelines suggest limiting juice to about one small glass a day and eating whole fruit for the rest. Eating the oranges instead of juicing them is also cheaper: one orange gives far more satisfaction than a third of a cup of juice.

Frequently asked questions

Is fresh orange juice cheaper than store-bought?

Usually not: about $1.44 a cup fresh against $0.56 a cup for a $4.50 half gallon.

How many oranges for a cup of juice?

About 3 juicing oranges, or 1 to 1.5 lb.

How much does fresh juice cost per year?

Seven cups a week cost about $524.16 a year, $319.41 more than store-bought.

How long does fresh orange juice keep?

Drink it within a day; keep leftovers cold and covered.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.