A high-deductible health plan (HDHP) has a lower monthly premium and a bigger deductible, and it lets you open a health savings account (HSA) with a tax deduction. A PPO or other lower-deductible plan costs more each month but pays sooner. The better plan depends on how much care you expect to use. This tool adds the premiums, your share of the medical bills up to the out-of-pocket limit, the employer HSA money and the tax saving on your HSA contribution.
How the calculation works
- Your bills = what you pay up to the deductible, then your share of the rest, never above the out-of-pocket maximum
- Net cost of the HDHP = 12 × the premium + your bills − the employer HSA money − your HSA contribution × your tax rate
- Net cost of the other plan = 12 × the premium + your bills
- Saving = the net cost of the other plan − the net cost of the HDHP
- Worst case = the yearly premiums + the out-of-pocket maximum
Example
With $4,000 of medical bills, the high-deductible plan costs $5,730 net after the HSA benefits, and the other plan costs $7,360. The difference is $1,630. In a very bad year, the worst-case cost is $10,370 for the HDHP and $10,760 for the other plan. The HDHP saves $2,160 in premiums.
Why it matters
Open enrollment is a yearly choice that affects hundreds or thousands of dollars. The comparison shows that the HDHP is often cheaper for people with low medical use and a generous employer HSA contribution, and that the other plan wins when you expect surgery, a pregnancy or regular treatment. The worst case figure matters too: you need the cash or the HSA balance to cover the deductible early in the year.
Good to know
The HSA is triple tax-advantaged only for a plan that meets the IRS definition of an HDHP: for 2026, a deductible of at least $1,700 for one person or $3,400 for a family, and an out-of-pocket maximum no more than $8,500 or $17,000. HSA contribution limits are $4,400 for one person and $8,750 for a family for 2026. This tool uses one deductible and one percentage, and ignores copays, network differences, drug costs, and any money left in the HSA that you keep for later years, which is an added benefit of the HDHP.
In practice
Check the summary of benefits of each plan, estimate your likely care using last year’s bills and keep receipts. This tool is educational and is not insurance or tax advice.