Skip to content
Omnikalc

Is homemade ice cream cheaper than store-bought?

Enter the batches a month, the batch size, the ingredient cost per batch, the machine price, the years you keep it and the store-bought price: get the homemade cost per quart, the yearly cost of each and the saving.

Updated on
Your inputs

Value out of range

qt

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

years

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

Results

Homemade per quart

$3.67

Saving per year

$84

Freeze the machine's bowl at least 24 hours, chill the base overnight, and use pasteurized eggs or a cooked custard; homemade ice cream is best within a week
Homemade per year
$132
Store-bought per year
$216

This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.

Making ice cream at home with a countertop machine is a treat, and it can also cost less than premium store-bought ice cream, depending on your ingredients. This calculator adds the ingredients and the machine, spread over the batches it makes in its life, and compares the cost per quart with store-bought.

How the calculation works

  • Batches per year = batches per month × 12
  • Cost per batch = ingredients + machine price ÷ years kept ÷ batches per year
  • Homemade per quart = cost per batch ÷ batch size
  • Homemade per year = cost per batch × batches per year
  • Store-bought per year = batches per year × batch size × store price per quart
  • Saving = store-bought per year − homemade per year

Two 1.5 quart batches a month at $5 of ingredients each, with a $60 ice cream maker kept 5 years, cost about $3.67 a quart, or $132 a year. The same amount of premium store-bought ice cream at $6 a quart costs $216, so homemade saves about $84 a year.

Ingredient costs

Style Main ingredients for 1.5 qt Typical cost
Philadelphia style 2 cups cream, 1 cup milk, sugar, vanilla $4 to $6
Custard (French) style cream, milk, 4 to 6 egg yolks, sugar $5 to $7
Sorbet fruit, sugar, water $3 to $6
Frozen yogurt yogurt, sugar, fruit $3 to $5

Good vanilla, nuts and chocolate can double the cost. Basic supermarket ice cream, often under $3 a quart, is cheaper than homemade, but premium brands at $6 to $10 a quart are not.

Ice cream makers

  • Freezer-bowl machines ($40 to $80) need the bowl frozen for at least 24 hours before each batch.
  • Compressor machines ($200 to $600) chill themselves and can make batch after batch, using about 0.1 to 0.2 kWh per batch.
  • Hand-crank machines with ice and rock salt are fun for parties and cost a few dollars in ice and salt per batch.

Tips for good results

Chill the base overnight so it churns faster and smoother. Cook custard bases to about 170°F to thicken them safely. Freeze the finished ice cream a few hours to firm up, and eat it within a week or two, before ice crystals form.

Frequently asked questions

Is homemade ice cream cheaper than store-bought?

Than premium ice cream, often: about $3.67 a quart here vs $6, but not than basic supermarket ice cream.

How much does a batch of homemade ice cream cost?

About $5 of ingredients for 1.5 quarts, plus about $0.50 of machine wear.

How much can an ice cream maker save?

About $84 a year for two batches a month.

How long does homemade ice cream keep?

Best within a week or two in the freezer.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.