An excess contribution is money you put into an IRA above the limit. The limit is the lower of the annual cap and your taxable compensation, and for a Roth IRA it can be reduced or removed at higher incomes. The IRS charges a 6 % excise tax on the excess every year it stays in the account. You can avoid the tax by withdrawing the excess and its earnings by the due date of your tax return, including extensions. This calculator shows the excess, the tax if you leave it and the cost of correcting.
How the calculation works
- Excess = what you contributed − your contribution limit, if positive
- Excise tax = excess × 6 % for each year it remains in the account
- Earnings = excess × ((1 + return)^years − 1)
- Cost of correcting = earnings × (marginal rate, plus 10 % if you are under 59½)
- Saved = excise tax − cost of correcting
Example
You put $9,000 into your IRAs, but your limit is $7,000, so the excess is $2,000. If it stays for 2 years, the excise tax is $240. If you remove the excess before the deadline, you also take out its earnings of $205, which are taxable, and since you are under 59½, they bear a 10 % penalty too. The cost is $70, which saves $170.
Why it matters
The 6 % tax repeats every year, so a small excess left alone for a decade can cost more than the excess itself earns. The common causes are Roth income limits, a contribution larger than your earnings, a missed rollover deadline and mixing up two tax years. Fixing the problem early is cheap, and the options include a corrective withdrawal, recharacterization to another IRA type or absorbing the excess in a later year.
Good to know
You can also absorb the excess by contributing less in the following year, but the 6 % tax still applies to the first year. A recharacterization moves the contribution and its earnings to a traditional IRA, which can work if you are above the Roth limit and below the traditional deduction limit. The deadline is the tax filing date with extensions, so a late fix may still be possible. Report the tax on Form 5329. The 10 % penalty on the earnings applies only if you are under 59½.
In practice
Ask your custodian for a “return of excess contribution” form with the earnings calculation, and file Form 5329 if you owe the 6 % tax. This tool is educational and is not tax advice.