A make-or-buy decision compares producing an item yourself with buying it from a supplier. The make or buy calculator takes the yearly volume, the supplier price, your variable cost, the avoidable fixed cost and the profit from freed capacity, and gives the yearly advantage of one option, the total and unit costs of both, and the break-even volume.
How the calculation works
- Cost of making = fixed cost + variable cost per unit × units. Include only the fixed costs that disappear if you stop making the item.
- Cost of buying = purchase price per unit × units, minus the profit from using the freed capacity (machines, space or staff) for something else.
- The advantage is the cost of buying minus the cost of making. A positive value means making is cheaper.
- The break-even volume is (fixed cost − freed-capacity profit) ÷ (purchase price − variable cost). Above it, making wins; below it, buying wins.
Example
A company needs 12,000 parts a year. A supplier sells them at $14.50. Making them costs $9.80 per part in variable cost plus $42,000 of fixed cost, and buying would free capacity worth $5,000 a year. Making costs $159,600, and buying costs $174,000 − $5,000 = $169,000, so making is cheaper by $9,400 a year. The cost per part is $13.30 to make and $14.08 net to buy. The break-even is 7,872 parts a year.
Why it matters
A supplier price often looks high next to the variable cost of making, and low once you add the fixed costs and the use of capacity. Putting all the costs side by side shows which option really costs less and how sensitive the answer is to volume.
Good to know
The comparison covers one year and a steady volume, with no change in price over time. It uses the avoidable fixed costs only, and it leaves out taxes, one-time costs of switching and the time value of money. Quality, risk and strategy often matter as much as the cost, so use the result as one input to the decision.
Related tools
The break-even calculator finds the volume at which revenue covers costs, and the lease versus buy calculator compares two ways to get an asset.