Americans on Medicare choose between two ways of covering what Original Medicare does not pay. Medigap (Medicare Supplement) is a policy that fills the gaps in Original Medicare, with a monthly premium and few or no costs when you use care, and you can see any doctor who takes Medicare. Medicare Advantage (Part C) replaces Original Medicare with a private plan, usually with a low or zero premium, but with copays, a network and an out-of-pocket maximum. In both cases you still pay the Part B premium. This calculator compares the yearly cost, the worst case and the spending where the two break even.
How the calculation works
- Medigap = Part B premium × 12 + Medigap premium × 12 + the Part B deductible (up to your spending)
- Medicare Advantage = Part B premium × 12 + plan premium × 12 + your cost share of spending, up to the out-of-pocket maximum
- Difference = Medigap cost − Medicare Advantage cost
- Worst case = the premiums plus the deductible for Medigap, or plus the out-of-pocket maximum for Medicare Advantage
- Break-even spending = (extra Medigap premium + deductible) ÷ Medicare Advantage cost share
Example
You expect $6,000 of covered medical spending. With Medigap at $160 a month, your yearly cost is $4,612. With Medicare Advantage at $0 a month and a 15 % cost share, it is $3,335, so Medigap costs $1,277 more. But in a bad year, Medicare Advantage can cost up to $11,785, compared with $4,612 for Medigap. The two cost the same at about $14,513 of spending.
Why it matters
Medicare Advantage is cheaper in a healthy year, and Medigap is cheaper in a year with a serious illness. The risk lies in the worst case: a high out-of-pocket maximum can mean a bill of thousands of dollars, and plan networks can limit your choice of specialists. Medigap premiums also tend to rise with age, and medical underwriting may apply if you try to switch to Medigap later.
Good to know
You have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you are 65 and enrolled in Part B, during which you cannot be refused. After it, insurers in most states can ask health questions. Medicare Advantage plans can change their benefits, network and costs every year, and you can switch during open enrollment from October to December. Prescription drugs (Part D) are separate with Medigap, and many Advantage plans include them. Dental and vision are often included in Advantage but not in Medigap.
In practice
Check the plan’s summary of benefits and your doctors’ networks, then compare quotes from several insurers. This tool is educational and is not insurance advice.