Skip to content
Omnikalc

Pay off your mortgage early or invest the money: which wins?

Enter your loan balance, rate, years left, the extra monthly money and an expected investment return to compare paying down the loan with investing.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

years

Value out of range

$

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

Results

Advantage of investing instead of paying down the loan

$20,070

Investing ends ahead at these returns, but the investment return is not guaranteed
Regular monthly payment
$1,688
Months to pay off the loan with the extra payment
179 months
Interest saved by paying extra
$115,670
Wealth at the original end date if you pay down the loan
$384,966
Wealth at the original end date if you invest the extra
$405,036

When you have extra money each month, two choices compete: pay the mortgage down faster or invest it. Paying down earns a certain return equal to your mortgage rate; investing may earn more but is uncertain. This calculator compares the wealth you would hold at the original end of the loan under both choices, and shows the interest saved by paying extra.

How the calculation works

  • Payment = standard amortized payment for the balance, rate and years left
  • Months to payoff = −ln(1 − balance × monthly rate ÷ (payment + extra)) ÷ ln(1 + monthly rate)
  • Interest saved = payment × original months − (payment + extra) × months to payoff
  • If you pay extra: after payoff you invest the whole payment for the remaining months
  • If you invest: you invest the extra every month for the full term
  • Advantage = wealth when investing − wealth when paying down

Example

A $250,000 balance at 6.5 % with 25 years left has a payment of about $1,688. Paying an extra $500 a month clears the loan in about 179 months and saves about $115,700 of interest. After that you invest the full $2,188 a month. Alternatively, you invest the $500 for 300 months at 7 %. The first path ends with about $385,000, the second with about $405,000, a small advantage of $20,000 for investing before taxes and risk.

Why it matters

The decision is not obvious when the mortgage rate and the likely return are close. Seeing both paths shows how sensitive the result is to the return: at a lower return, paying down wins, and the margin shrinks quickly when you account for risk.

Good to know

The model assumes a steady return, which real markets do not offer, and ignores taxes, deductions and fees. Many people choose a mix: pay down some of the loan and invest the rest, or fill tax-advantaged accounts first. This is an educational estimate, not advice.

The extra mortgage payment calculator details the time and interest saved, the mortgage payoff calculator plans a payoff date, and the compound interest calculator projects an investment.

Frequently asked questions

Should I pay off my mortgage early or invest?

It depends on how your mortgage rate compares with what you can reasonably earn after tax, and on how much risk you can accept. Paying down a loan is a guaranteed return equal to the mortgage rate; investing may earn more but can lose.

How is the comparison done?

In one case you add the extra money to the payment and pay off sooner, then invest the whole payment until the original end date. In the other you keep the regular payment and invest the extra every month. The wealth at the original end date is then compared.

Which return should I enter?

Use a conservative, after-tax estimate. Stocks have averaged around 7 percent a year after inflation over very long periods, but with large swings. Using a lower return shows how much the answer changes.

What does the model leave out?

Mortgage interest deductions, taxes on investment gains in a regular account, prepayment penalties, the value of liquidity and the peace of mind of being debt-free. These can swing the result in either direction.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.