A permanent policy such as whole life costs many times more than a term policy for the same death benefit, because part of the premium builds a cash value. The classic question is whether it is better to buy term and invest the difference. This calculator compares the value of the extra money invested yourself with the cash value promised by the permanent policy.
How the calculation works
- Difference = premium of the permanent policy − premium of the term policy
- Value of the invested difference = difference × ((1 + r)ⁿ − 1) ÷ r, with premiums paid at year end
- Advantage = value of the invested difference − cash value of the policy
- Total extra premiums = difference × number of years
- Growth = value of the invested difference − total extra premiums
Example
A term policy costs $600 a year and a permanent policy $6,000. You invest the $5,400 difference each year at 6 % for 20 years. The investment grows to $198,642, of which $90,642 is growth on $108,000 paid in. The permanent policy shows a cash value of $105,000. In this case term and invest comes out $93,642 ahead, before taxes and fees.
Why it matters
Life insurance is two products in one: protection and savings. Separating them often makes each cheaper and more flexible, but only if you actually invest the difference every year and keep the discipline. A permanent policy forces the saving and may offer tax advantages, guarantees and coverage for life.
Good to know
The comparison stops at the end of the term. After that, the term cover ends, while the permanent policy still pays a death benefit, and a new term policy at an older age costs far more. The cash value in early years is usually low because of commissions. Use the guaranteed column of the illustration to be prudent, and remember that the investment return is not guaranteed. Taxes on your own investments and on policy gains differ by country.
In practice
Run the calculator with several returns, for instance 3 %, 6 % and 8 %, and with the guaranteed and the projected cash value. If you need cover for life, to pass on wealth or to fund a special need, a permanent policy can still make sense. This tool is for education and is not insurance or investment advice.