Skip to content
Omnikalc

Roth conversion calculator: is converting your IRA worth the tax?

Enter the amount, your tax rate today and in retirement, the years and the return to compare a Roth conversion with leaving the money in the traditional IRA.

Updated on
Your inputs
$

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

years

Value out of range

%

Value out of range

% of the return

Value out of range

Results

Converting minus not converting (value at withdrawal, after tax)

$1,696

Converting wins: the tax-free growth outweighs the tax you pay today
Tax due on the conversion this year
$7,200
Roth IRA value at withdrawal (tax-free)
$96,214
No conversion: after-tax IRA plus the invested tax money
$94,518
Break-even tax rate in retirement
20.2%

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth IRA. You pay income tax on the amount now, and the money then grows and comes out tax-free. Whether that is a good trade depends on how much tax you pay today compared with what you would pay later. This calculator compares the two paths and shows the break-even tax rate in retirement.

How the calculation works

  • Tax on the conversion = amount converted × tax rate today
  • Roth value = amount × (1 + return)^years, withdrawn tax-free
  • Without a conversion = amount × growth × (1 − retirement tax rate) + tax money invested in a taxable account
  • Taxable account growth = (1 + return × (1 − tax drag))^years
  • Break-even rate = tax rate today × taxable growth ÷ IRA growth

The tax on the conversion is assumed to be paid from other savings, which is why the comparison includes what that money would have earned.

Example

You convert $30,000 and pay 24 %, or $7,200, from savings. Over 20 years at 6 % the Roth grows to $96,214. Without the conversion, the IRA grows to the same amount but is taxed at 22 % on withdrawal, leaving $75,047, and the $7,200 you kept grows to $19,471 in a taxable account at a 15 % tax drag: $94,518 in all. Converting is ahead by $1,696, and the break-even retirement rate is 20.2 %.

Why it matters

Conversions are one of the few tax moves with a lasting effect, and they cannot be undone. A conversion at the top of a bracket can cost far more than one that fills a low bracket. Seeing the break-even rate lets you test your own forecast: if you are sure your rate will be lower later, don’t convert.

Good to know

A conversion raises your income for the year and can affect Medicare premiums, the taxation of Social Security, and eligibility for credits and aid. Each conversion has its own five-year clock for penalty-free withdrawal of the converted amount before age 59½. Rates and rules change, and state taxes matter. This tool is for education and is not tax advice.

The Roth vs traditional calculator compares the two accounts for new contributions, the retirement savings calculator projects a nest egg, and the federal income tax calculator finds your bracket.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Roth conversion?

It moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth IRA. The amount converted counts as ordinary income for the year, so you pay tax on it now, and in exchange the money and its future growth can be withdrawn tax-free in retirement.

Should I pay the tax from the converted money?

It is better to pay it from other savings. Paying from the converted amount shrinks the Roth balance and, before age 59½, can add a 10 percent penalty on the part used. This calculator assumes the tax comes from outside money that would otherwise have been invested in a taxable account.

When does a conversion make sense?

A conversion tends to pay when your tax rate today is low compared with the rate you expect later: a year with less income, a gap before Social Security or required distributions start, or a market drop. It also helps heirs and removes required distributions on the converted money.

What is the break-even rate?

It is the tax rate in retirement at which converting and not converting leave you with the same amount. If you expect to pay a higher rate than that in retirement, converting wins. Below it, keeping the money in the traditional account does.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.