A Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) lets Canadians deduct contributions from their income and grow the money tax-deferred. You get a tax refund now, and you pay tax on withdrawals later. The Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) works the other way: no deduction now, but no tax later. This calculator shows the refund, the net cost of your contribution and the after-tax value of an RRSP against a TFSA that costs the same.
How the calculation works
- Deduction = the smaller of your contribution and your unused RRSP room
- Refund = deduction × your marginal tax rate today
- Net cost = contribution − refund
- RRSP after tax = contribution × (1 + return) ^ years × (1 − tax rate at withdrawal)
- TFSA with the same net cost = net cost × (1 + return) ^ years, with no tax
- If you contribute above your room (and above the $2,000 cushion), a penalty of 1 % a month applies to the excess
Example
You contribute $10,000 with $18,000 of room and a 31 % marginal rate. The refund is $3,100 and the net cost is $6,900. In 25 years at 6 %, the RRSP is worth a lot more before tax, and after a 22 % tax on withdrawal it leaves $33,477. The TFSA that costs the same net amount grows to $29,614. The RRSP is ahead by $3,863, because the tax rate falls from 31 % to 22 %.
Why it matters
The general rule is simple: an RRSP is better when your marginal rate is higher now than in retirement, and a TFSA is better when it is lower now, for example at the start of a career. When the rates are equal, the two are equivalent, as long as you reinvest the refund. Many people use both, and put the RRSP refund into a TFSA.
Good to know
Your RRSP room is 18 % of last year’s earned income, up to a yearly maximum, plus unused room carried forward. Contributions made in the first 60 days of the year can be deducted for the previous year. RRSP withdrawals are added to your income and taxed, and may reduce income-tested benefits such as Old Age Security or the Canada Child Benefit. At 71, an RRSP must be converted to a RRIF with minimum withdrawals. Programs such as the Home Buyers’ Plan allow tax-free withdrawals under conditions.
In practice
Find your exact room on your Notice of Assessment, compare your rate today with your expected rate in retirement and keep the refund invested. This tool is educational and is not tax advice.