This calculator gives estimates for education and planning. It is not investment, tax or legal advice; for decisions about your own situation, talk to a qualified financial professional.
Buying secondhand, at thrift stores, garage sales or online marketplaces, can cut the cost of clothes, toys, books, furniture and equipment by more than half. Reselling what you no longer use adds a little more. This calculator estimates what you save in a year compared with buying everything new.
How the calculation works
- Saved by buying used = items × share bought used × new price × (1 − used price share)
- Total saved = saved by buying used + resale income
- Net spending = cost of buying everything new − total saved
Say you buy 30 items a year that cost $35 new on average. If you buy half of them used at 40% of the new price, you save 15 × $35 × 0.6 = $315. Add $100 from reselling things you no longer use, and the total is $415 a year, 39.5% less than buying all new. Your net spending on these items falls from $1,050 to $635.
What is worth buying used
- Kids’ clothes and toys, which are outgrown long before they wear out.
- Books, games and sports gear for a hobby you are trying out.
- Solid wood furniture, often better made than cheap new pieces.
- Tools and kitchen equipment, which last for decades.
- Formal wear and costumes worn only a few times.
What to be careful with
- Safety items: car seats, bike helmets and cribs may have hidden damage or no longer meet current safety standards.
- Electronics with no warranty and an unknown battery state.
- Mattresses and upholstered items, which can carry pests.
- Items with recalls: check the model before buying.
Getting the most from secondhand
- Keep a list of what you need, and shop for it, rather than buying bargains you did not plan.
- Inspect seams, zippers and moving parts before you pay.
- Shop at the end of the season and in better-off neighborhoods for higher-quality pieces.
- Resell regularly: sell clothes and gear while they are still in season and in demand.
The saving only counts if you would have bought it
The figure assumes the secondhand items replace things you would have bought new anyway. Cheap prices can make it easy to buy more than you need; extra items are spending, not savings. Used well, secondhand shopping saves money and keeps useful things out of the trash.