Payments from an annuity bought with after-tax money are only partly taxable. Each payment includes a return of your own money, which is not taxed again, and earnings, which are taxed as ordinary income. The exclusion ratio splits each payment between the two. This calculator shows the tax-free part, the taxable part, the tax per year and how long the tax-free portion lasts.
How the calculation works
- Expected return = yearly payment × expected number of years of payments
- Exclusion ratio = investment in the contract ÷ expected return
- Tax-free part of each payment = payment × exclusion ratio
- Taxable part = payment − tax-free part
- Years of exclusion = investment ÷ tax-free part per year
- Once you have recovered your investment, the whole payment is taxable
Example
You paid $100,000 after tax for an annuity that pays $7,200 a year, and the expected payment period is 20 years. The expected return is $144,000, so the exclusion ratio is 69.4 %. Each year, $5,000 is tax-free and $2,200 is taxable, which costs about $484 at 22 %. The tax-free part lasts 20.0 years, since you recover your $100,000 in 20 years if payments run as expected. After that, all payments are taxable, with a tax of about $1,584 a year.
Why it matters
The ratio shows the real after-tax income of an annuity and helps compare it with other sources, such as bond interest or withdrawals from an investment account. It also helps with planning: payments are lightly taxed in the first years and fully taxed later, which affects the brackets and the taxes on Social Security benefits. If you die before recovering the investment, the unrecovered amount may be deducted on your final return.
Good to know
The exclusion ratio applies to non-qualified annuities paid for with after-tax money. For annuities in an IRA or 401(k), where contributions were deductible, the whole payment is generally taxable unless there is after-tax basis. For life annuities, the expected return uses the IRS life expectancy tables for the age at the starting date. For variable annuities the rules are different, since the payment changes. Annuities with withdrawals before the payout starts follow a last-in, first-out rule, where earnings are taxed first. The 10 % penalty can apply to early withdrawals of the earnings. State taxes vary.
In practice
Ask the insurer for the investment in the contract and the exclusion amount, which appear on Form 1099-R, and compare them with your estimate. This tool is educational and is not tax advice.