Overstocking is one of the most common mistakes in a new aquarium. This calculator uses the classic inch-per-gallon rule, corrected for the water displaced by gravel and decor, to estimate how many fish of a given adult size a freshwater tank can hold.
The rule
The traditional rule is about 1 in of adult fish length per gallon of water. A 20 gallon tank with about 85% usable water after gravel, rocks and decor holds about 17 gallons, so about 17 in of fish. With fish that grow to 2 in, that is about 8 fish.
Always use the adult size of the fish, not the size in the store.
Limits of the rule
The rule is a rough starting point for small, slim community fish such as tetras, rasboras and small livebearers. It works poorly for:
- Large or heavy-bodied fish: a 10 in fish produces far more waste than ten 1 in fish. Goldfish, cichlids and plecos need much more space than the rule suggests.
- Active swimmers: fast fish such as danios need long tanks.
- Territorial fish: many cichlids and bettas need space and hiding places, not just volume.
- Schooling fish: many species should be kept in groups of 6 or more, which shapes what you can add.
Filtration, plants and water changes also affect how many fish a tank can support. A lightly stocked tank is more stable and forgiving.
Stocking safely
- Cycle the tank first: let beneficial bacteria build up in the filter before adding fish, which can take several weeks.
- Add fish gradually, a few at a time, so the bacteria can keep up with the extra waste.
- Test the water for ammonia, nitrite and nitrate after each addition.
- Check compatibility: temperature, water hardness, temperament and adult size.
- Quarantine new fish in a separate tank if possible to avoid introducing disease.
Signs of overstocking
Cloudy water, rising ammonia or nitrate, fish gasping at the surface, frequent aggression and algae outbreaks can all point to too many fish for the tank and filter. Rehoming a few fish or upgrading the tank solves it.