Adding insulation does not always reduce heat loss. For a small pipe, wire or sphere, a thin layer can make it worse. This critical insulation radius calculator finds the critical radius from the shape, the bare radius, the conductivity of the insulation and the outside heat transfer coefficient, and gives the thickness needed and the heat loss at the critical radius compared with the bare object.
How the calculation works
- Choose the shape (a cylinder such as a pipe or a wire, or a sphere) and enter the outer radius of the bare object, the conductivity of the insulation and the outside heat transfer coefficient.
- The critical radius is r = k / h for a cylinder and r = 2k / h for a sphere.
- Below this radius, a thin layer of insulation increases the heat loss, because the outer area grows faster than the resistance of the layer.
- The calculator also gives the thickness needed to reach the critical radius and the heat loss at that radius compared with the bare object.
Example
A bare wire of 0.06 in radius is covered with an insulation of k = 1.18 BTU·in/h·ft²·°F in air with h = 1.76 BTU/h·ft²·°F. The critical radius of the cylinder is k / h = 0.670 in, so the insulation must be 0.610 in thick before it begins to help. At that radius, the heat loss is 3.3 times that of the bare wire.
Why it matters
The critical radius explains a surprising effect, and it helps when designing the insulation of small tubes, refrigerant lines, electric wires and heating elements. If the bare radius is below the critical radius, the insulation must be thick enough to pass it, or else it should be left out, or a better insulator with lower conductivity must be used.
Good to know
The calculator is for steady conduction through a uniform insulation layer and for a constant outside coefficient h, which includes convection and radiation. It ignores the contact resistance, the change of conductivity with temperature, the resistance of the pipe wall and of the fluid inside, and the effect of the diameter on h, which becomes lower for a larger outside diameter. For a pipe, the loss per unit length is the quantity considered.
Related tools
The heat conduction calculator covers the flow through a layer, the wall U-value calculator covers building walls, the insulation calculator sizes a layer for a building, and the heat loss calculator estimates the total loss.