Skip to content
Omnikalc

Piping safety factor calculator: is the soil safe against boiling?

Enter the head difference, the seepage path, the exit gradient factor, the specific gravity and the void ratio to get the critical gradient, the exit gradient, the safety factor against piping and the head that causes boiling.

Updated on
Your inputs
ft

Value out of range

ft

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Value out of range

Results

Safety factor against piping

2.62

Safe against piping with a normal margin
Critical hydraulic gradient ic = (Gs − 1) / (1 + e)
0.982
Exit hydraulic gradient
0.375
Buoyant unit weight of the soil
61.30 pcf
Seepage force per unit volume
23.40 pcf
Head difference that causes boiling
26.20 ft

Piping or boiling happens when the upward seepage gradient at an exit reaches the critical hydraulic gradient of the soil. The piping safety factor calculator computes the critical gradient, the exit gradient, the safety factor and the head difference that causes boiling.

How the calculation works

  • Enter the head difference between the upstream and downstream water levels, and the length of the seepage path along the base of the structure or around the sheet pile, in feet.
  • Enter the exit gradient factor: 1 for the average gradient, and 1.5 to 2.5 near a sheet pile or a cutoff, where the flow lines concentrate at the downstream face.
  • Enter the specific gravity of the grains and the void ratio of the soil at the exit. The calculator computes the critical gradient ic = (Gs − 1) / (1 + e), the gradient at which the effective stress is zero.
  • The safety factor against piping is ic divided by the exit gradient. A value of 1.5 or more is a common minimum for an excavation, and 3 or more for a dam.

Example

A cofferdam has a head difference of 10 ft and a seepage path of 40 ft, with an exit gradient factor of 1.5. The soil at the exit has Gs = 2.67 and e = 0.70. The critical gradient is 1.67 / 1.70 = 0.982. The exit gradient is 1.5 × 10 / 40 = 0.375. The safety factor against piping is 0.982 / 0.375 = 2.62. The soil has a buoyant unit weight of 61.30 pcf, the seepage force is 23.40 pcf, and boiling would need a head difference of 26.20 ft.

Why it matters

The calculator helps civil and geotechnical engineers, contractors who dig below the water table, and students to check the base of a cofferdam, a deep excavation, a sheet pile wall or a small dam against boiling, and to see what a longer cutoff or a lower head would change. It is a quick screening before a full seepage analysis.

Good to know

Use the void ratio of the loosest soil at the exit, since it governs. Raise the exit gradient factor near a cutoff wall, and use a flow net or a finite element model for the final design. Add a filter or a weighted blanket at the exit to raise the safety factor. Lower the water table by dewatering when the margin is small.

Darcy’s law calculator gives the seepage flow, the soil permeability test calculator measures the permeability, the porosity and void ratio calculator gives e and the infinite slope stability calculator covers the effect of seepage on a slope.

Frequently asked questions

What is piping or boiling?

When water flows upward through a soil at the downstream face of a dam, a sheet pile wall or the bottom of an excavation, the seepage force acts against the weight of the soil. If the upward force equals the buoyant weight of the soil, the effective stress falls to zero. The grains lose their contact, the soil boils and loses its strength, and a channel can grow back toward the source of water, the failure that is called piping.

What is the critical hydraulic gradient?

The critical gradient ic is the gradient at which the seepage force equals the buoyant weight of the soil: ic = γ′ / γw = (Gs − 1) / (1 + e). For most sands it is close to 1. A loose sand has a lower critical gradient than a dense one, since it has a higher void ratio and so a lower buoyant weight.

What safety factor should I use?

A safety factor of 1.5 to 2 is often used for a temporary excavation in a granular soil, with a check by the engineer. For a permanent structure such as a dam or a weir, values of 3 to 4 are common, since a failure can be sudden and disastrous. Local codes and the geotechnical report give the required value for the project.

What are the limits of this calculator?

The exit gradient depends on the geometry of the flow, which is found with a flow net or a seepage analysis, and the average gradient ΔH / L underestimates it. The factor that you enter is a rough allowance for that effect. The calculator also does not model heave of a layered soil, internal erosion of a soil with a gap-graded fabric, or the effect of a filter. Use a seepage analysis for design.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.