Skip to content
Omnikalc

Roof ponding instability and framing stiffness calculator

Enter the spans, the joist spacing and the moments of inertia of the girders, the joists and the deck to check a flat roof against ponding instability and to get the minimum inertia.

Updated on
Your inputs
ft

Value out of range

ft

Value out of range

ft

Value out of range

in⁴

Value out of range

in⁴

Value out of range

in⁴/ft

Value out of range

Results

Stiffness check Cp + 0.9 Cs

0.203

At or below 0.25: the framing is stiff enough against ponding instability
Primary member flexibility Cp
0.0972
Secondary member flexibility Cs
0.1178
Minimum moment of inertia of a secondary member
76.3 in⁴
Minimum moment of inertia of the deck
0.0156 in⁴/ft
Deck inertia to the minimum
16.0

The roof ponding instability calculator applies the AISC flexibility check Cp + 0.9 Cs ≤ 0.25 to a flat roof framed with primary and secondary members and gives the minimum inertia of the secondary members and of the deck.

How the calculation works

  • Enter the spans of the primary and secondary members and the spacing of the secondary members.
  • Enter the moment of inertia of a primary member, of a secondary member and of the deck per foot of width.
  • The calculator gives the flexibility coefficients, the stiffness check Cp + 0.9 Cs and the minimum inertia of the secondary members and of the deck.

Example

A flat roof has primary girders spanning 30 ft, joists spanning 30 ft at 5 ft, with Ip = 800 in⁴, Is = 110 in⁴ and a deck of 0.25 in⁴/ft. The flexibility of the girders is Cp = 32 × 30 × 30⁴ / (10⁷ × 800) = 0.0972, and that of the joists is Cs = 32 × 5 × 30⁴ / (10⁷ × 110) = 0.1178. The check Cp + 0.9 Cs = 0.203 is below 0.25, so the framing is stiff enough. The joists need at least 76.3 in⁴ with this girder, and the deck needs at least 0.0156 in⁴/ft.

Why it matters

The calculator helps structural engineers, steel detailers, roofing designers and students to check that the framing of a low-slope roof is not at risk of a runaway pond, and to see how a change in span or in member size changes the result.

Good to know

Use the moments of inertia of the members as they are, with the composite action only if the roof deck is attached to take it. Take the span of the primary members as the column spacing in the direction of the girders, and the span of the secondary members as the distance between girders. If the check is not met, increase the inertia of the secondary members first, then the girders. Roofs with a slope of 1/4 in per foot or more to the drains, with drains that are well kept, are much less at risk, but the check is still part of the standard for flat roofs.

The rain load calculator gives the ponding depth with a blocked drain, the scupper calculator sizes the secondary drains, the composite metal deck calculator gives the concrete over a ponding deck and the beam deflection calculator gives the deflection of a member.

Frequently asked questions

What is ponding instability?

On a flat or nearly flat roof, rain collects in the low points made by the deflection of the framing. The water weighs more, so the framing bends more, so more water collects. If the framing is too flexible, this cycle never stops and the roof can collapse, even if the rain is not heavy and the drains work.

What is the AISC check?

Appendix 2 of AISC 360 asks that Cp + 0.9 Cs be 0.25 or less, where Cp = 32 Ls Lp⁴ / (10⁷ Ip) for the primary members and Cs = 32 S Ls⁴ / (10⁷ Is) for the secondary members, with spans and spacing in feet and inertias in in⁴. The deck needs Id of at least 25 S⁴ / 10⁶ in⁴ per foot.

How do I make a roof stiffer?

The secondary members are usually the cheapest place to add stiffness, since the Cs term goes with the fourth power of their span. Make the primary members deeper, add camber so that the roof slopes to the drains, shorten the span, or raise the slope of the roof. A slope of 1/4 in per foot to the drains is the usual rule.

What does the calculator leave out?

The calculator leaves out the real depth of the pond on the roof, the clogged drain condition, the effect of the camber, the stiffness of the connections and the rain load for the secondary drains. Check the rain load on the roof with a blocked drain, and design the secondary drains and scuppers.

Was this calculator helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Results are estimates provided for information purposes. They do not replace professional advice.